1. The abstract and methods state the review employed a “PRISMA-guided literature search… to enhance transparency.” However, Section 2 explicitly notes that no protocol was registered and formal risk-of-bias tools were not applied. Furthermore, excluding 41 full-text articles simply for “lack of relevance to oral cellular mechanisms” is exceptionally broad. Could you clarify how this approach aligns with PRISMA standards, and what specific, predefined criteria were used to define that “relevance” to mitigate selection bias?
2. While reviewing Table 1, I noticed several duplication and indexing errors that raise concerns about the rigor of the data extraction. For instance, Reference [11] (Rus et al., 2025) is listed twice under Domain B with contradictory study types (“Clinical/experimental review” vs. “Human biomarker study”). Similarly, References [34] (Nittayananta, 2026) and [54] (Shibata et al., 2025) appear duplicated across different domains.
3. There is a notable contradiction between your limitations and your final recommendations. In Sections 3.8 and 4.3, you rightly concede that “causal pathways linking occupational stress to oral cellular dysregulation cannot be established with confidence” due to the predominance of cross-sectional designs. Yet, the Abstract and Conclusion actively advocate for the “systematic integration of salivary and mucosal biomarkers into workplace wellbeing programs.” How do you justify recommending practical, systemic integration based on evidence you yourselves admit lacks causal resolution and longitudinal validation?
4. Figure 5 details specific intracellular human pathways (e.g., NF-κB, MAPK, Treg expansion) in response to postbiotics and probiotics. However, Section 3.5.2 explicitly notes that this experimental evidence is “primarily demonstrated in preclinical models.” Presenting these unverified preclinical mechanisms so definitively in a central conceptual figure risks misleading readers into believing this is already an established pathway in human occupational stress.