1. Why is there a fundamental discrepancy between your similarity matrix and dendrogram? Table 4 shows G5 and G8 with the lowest similarity (0.14), yet in Figure 4 they are not positioned as the most distant pairs. Additionally, G1 and G3 show 0.96 similarity but Figure 6 places them in different clusters (G1 in cluster I, G3 in cluster II). This contradiction undermines your clustering interpretation.
2. Your PCA biplot (Figure 3) claims Dim1 explains 97.6% of variation, but with 12 traits and 10 genotypes, such extreme variance concentration is statistically improbable. Did you use standardized or non-standardized data? This suggests either data transformation errors or that your traits are highly redundant—yet you treat them as independent descriptors.
3. The STRUCTURE analysis (Figure 7) shows admixture patterns, but you never report the optimal K value via ΔK or LnP(D) plots. Your text mentions “three major groups” but Figure 7 appears to show K=2 or K=3 without clear justification. What was the actual optimal K, and why wasn’t the ΔK plot included?
4. Your genotype numbering in the STRUCTURE bar plot (Figure 7) does not match the 10 genotypes listed in Table 1—there appear to be 11 bars. Can you clarify this inconsistency? This suggests either a data entry error or mislabeling that compromises all downstream analyses.
5. For ISSR markers, you screened 12 primers but used only 8 polymorphic ones. However, primers with low PIC values (UBC-828: 0.116) produce unreliable clustering. Why include markers with PIC <0.20 when they contribute noise rather than meaningful genetic distances? This artificially inflates similarity coefficients.
6. Your genetic similarity range (0.14–0.96) is unusually broad for 10 genotypes of the same species collected from the same country. Could this extreme range be an artifact of using monomorphic primers in your initial screening, which you discarded, rather than genuine diversity?
1. Conflicting cluster memberships across sections. The abstract reports three groups (I: G8, G2, G10, G5, G1; II: G7, G4; III: G9, G3, G6). The Results (Fig. 4 description) state cluster I contains “six” genotypes but lists seven (G8, G2, G10, G5, G1, G7, G4) and cluster II contains three (G9, G3, G6). The Discussion later states cluster I includes G1, G3, G5, G7, G9, which contradicts Fig. 4 where G3 and G9 fall in the second cluster. Please reconcile these mutually exclusive groupings.
2. Table 4 contains a non-existent “G11” column. Only ten genotypes (G1–G10) are described. Please correct the header.
3. Primer number discrepancy. The text states “12 ISSR primers were screened, and 8 polymorphic primers were selected,” yet Table 3 lists 10 primers (UBC-812, 814, 815, 816, 818, 822, 826, 827, 828, 829). Please clarify how many primers were actually used.
4. Unsubstantiated polymorphism percentage. The text claims “65.85% polymorphism” for UBC-812, UBC-815, and UBC-818, but these three primers show 14 loci and 14 polymorphic bands (100%). Across all 10 primers in Table 3, the polymorphism is 26/41 = 63.4%, not 65.85%. Please show the calculation.
5. Non-existent primer. The text refers to “UBC-15” as having lower Cj values, but this primer does not appear in Table 3.
6. Abbreviation errors. Table 1 footnote defines “LW leaf area,” but the text consistently uses “leaf width.” Table 2 footnote defines “AA antioxidant activity,” but the text uses AA for ascorbic acid. Please correct both.
7. Incorrect similarity claim. The text states “G6 and G8 showed the highest level of similarity,” but Table 4 shows G1–G3 = 0.96 and G2–G4 = 0.96, both higher than G6–G8 = 0.92.
8. Heatmap description does not match Fig. 5. The text states “G4, G7, and G2 showed relatively higher values… placed at the upper end of the dendrogram,” but the heatmap shows G8, G2, G10 at the upper end. Please verify.
9. Conclusion contradicts Table 3. The text claims “UBC-812 and UBC-827 confirmed the highest efficiency,” but UBC-818 has higher PIC (0.296 vs. 0.264) than UBC-827, and UBC-812 has the highest Dj. Please state the criterion used.
10. Population structure contradicts the abstract. The abstract claims “three main groups” based on STRUCTURE, but Fig. 7 shows the highest ΔK peaks at K = 7 and K = 9. Please state the optimal K and reconcile this with the three-group claim.
11. Irrelevant citations. Numerous references are unrelated to pepino or the methods used (e.g., Feng et al. 2025 on DNA methylation prediction; Sitorus et al. 2025 on shallot; Sarikaya et al. 2025 on vegetable legumes; Bankole et al. 2025 on sorghum; Hasddin and Ulyasniati 2025 on biostimulants; Kioko et al. 2024 on pulses in Kenya; Lodi et al. 2025 on a fungus; Shahid et al. 2024 on CRISPR; Shahwar et al. 2024 on watermelon; Zhang et al. 2023 on Catalpa bungei; Zhou et al. 2022 on eggplant; Chinnkar and Jadhav 2024 on lycopene cyclase). Please justify.
12. Confounded experimental design. Genotypes were collected from different locations and evaluated at those locations, completely confounding genetic effects with environmental effects. No common-garden experiment was performed, so the claimed “genetic diversity” cannot be separated from phenotypic plasticity.
13. Missing replication and statistics. The number of individuals per genotype used for DNA extraction is not stated. ANOVA results (F-values, p-values, df) are not presented. Please provide.
14. Duplicated text. The sentence “The broader genetic similarity range (0.14–0.96) reflects the presence of both conserved genomic regions and highly divergent alleles…” appears twice in the Discussion.
15. Typographical error. “ batter genotype” !!!!! should be “better”? (Abstract and Conclusion)