There are several critical aspects of this paper that require clarification from the authors. The study heavily relies on simulation results, yet it lacks experimental validation and transparency in detailing simulation parameters, which raises concerns about the reproducibility of its findings. Claims of significant improvements in reliability and efficiency for hybrid UPS systems using adaptive droop control are not supported by real-world testing or comparative benchmarks. Additionally, the simulation data exhibits inconsistencies and unexplained deviations in power-sharing behavior, suggesting potential gaps in the robustness of the methodology. Selective reporting of results further undermines confidence in the study’s reliability. Compounding these issues are citation mismatches and an absence of engagement with recent advancements in hybrid energy systems, which detracts from the study’s relevance and accuracy. Addressing these issues is crucial to ensure that the paper does not inadvertently mislead the scientific community.
